What All Decaffeination Processes Have In Common
Before we look at any specific decaffeination process lets see what they share in common as a group.
- Coffee is always decaffeinated in its green state.
- The greatest challenge is to try to separate only the caffeine from the coffee beans while leaving the other chemicals at their original concentrations. This is not easy since coffee contains somewhere around 1,000 chemicals that are important to the taste and aroma of this wonderfully complex elixir.
- Since caffeine is a water-soluble substance, water is used in all forms of decaffeination.
- However, water is not the best solution for decaffeination. Water is not a selective solvent and therefore removes other soluble substances, like sugars and proteins, as well as caffeine. Therefore, all decaffeination processes use a decaffeinating agent . These agents help speed up the process and minimize the washed-out effects that water alone would have on the taste of decaf coffee.
How Is Decaffeinated Coffee Made
Coffee = caffeine. Caffeine = energy boost.
But not everyone who drinks coffee likes the effect of caffeine on their day-to-day existence or simply due to health reasons are unable to consume.
These people luckily have an option in the form of decaffeinated coffee. But what does this mean? And how do they remove caffeine from coffee?
Lets start off by confirmed that, yes, coffee does contain a good amount of caffeine, but contrary to what you thought coffee actually has less caffeine that tea.
But thats not exactly correct, yes, tea has more caffeine in an unbrewed dry leaf form on average. But coffee has more in a brewed form.
On average a cup of tea provides 40mg vs 105mg in the average cup of drip coffee, so just over 2 ¼ cups of tea equal the caffeine boost of an average cup of coffee.
Granted this doesnt take into account the beans, length of brew time and a few other key factors, its at least a solid indication of the differences between the two hot drinks.
So if we have to get rid of this theoretical average of 105mg per cup of drip coffee, how are we going to go about it?
The Swiss Water Method
The Swiss Water decaf method is the only fully organic method. It uses no chemical solvents other than water itself. No carbon dioxide, no lab-made chemicals, only water.
This method is a patented process by Coffex, a coffee company in Switzerland, though the actual processing happens in Canada.
In this method, the green coffee beans are soaked in warm, pressurized water. The contents of the beans are released into the water as the pores of the beans open up. This big batch of brewed green coffee extract is forced through an activated charcoal filter, which traps the caffeine but lets everything else through.
The now flavorless green coffee is discarded and new beans are added. The green coffee extract is added to these beans. The caffeine is extracted like normal, but the sugars, oils, and other flavor compounds remain in the beans .
Swiss Water decaf coffee has become the specialty coffee standard. Though its a little more expensive than using a chemical solvent, its clean and does a good job of taking out caffeine while preserving flavors.
Recommended Reading: How Much Is An Iced Coffee At Mcdonalds
Does Decaf Tea Have Caffeine
There are two types of decaf tea: one is real tea that’s been decaffeinated, and the other is herbal tea, which doesn’t have caffeine from the start. Tip: If you make a cup of tea, dump it, and use the same tea bag a second time, you’ll get almost all of the tea flavor and only a fraction of the caffeine.
How To Decaffeinate Coffee Yourself
Most people choose to buy their decaffeinated coffee in a grocery store or in a coffee shop, but you may decide to decaffeinate coffee yourself. This could be because you dont want to purchase different kinds of coffee for your household or you want to be able to control it yourself. Making your own decaf coffee isnt precisely hard, but it is time-consuming and requires some patience.
Most people choose to buy their decaffeinated coffee in a grocery store or in a coffee shop, but you may decide to decaffeinate coffee yourself. This could be because you dont want to purchase different kinds of coffee for your household or you want to be able to control it yourself.
Read Also: Who Makes Jura Coffee Machines
Wondering How Do They Make Decaffeinated Coffee
Wondering how do they make decaffeinated coffee? One of the primary reasons people drink coffee is to wake up. Whether in the morning or during an exhausting workday.
When you drink decaffeinated coffee, however, you will have a totally different experience. Without caffeine, the effect on your brain is considerably milder.
When we consume caffeine, caffeine molecules compete with a molecule called adenosine for binding to specific receptors in the brain.
Typically, when these receptors detect a high adenosine level, they transmit a command that slows down brain activity. Which causes fatigue and drowsiness.
There is a structural similarity between caffeine and adenosine. That allows caffeine to replace the adenosine on the brain receptors and prevent the feeling of fatigue.
Despite the increased vigilance that accompanies drinking coffee, and perhaps because of it, many people choose to drink decaffeinated coffee.
About ten percent of global coffee consumption is of decaffeinated coffee.
But is free coffee decaffeinated? How is caffeine separated from coffee and does this process involve health hazards?
Is Decaffeinated Coffee Better Than Regular Coffee
This is a loaded question, well, in my opinion, because it really depends on what you hope to get out of your coffee. If you want a morning jolt, then decaffeinated coffee is not going to do it for you.
As we have seen, the health benefits are about the same between decaf and caffeinated coffee and the drawbacks are largely tied to the amount of caffeine and how much other stuff you add to your drink.
So really, it depends on what you want your morning mug to do for you. If you need a wake-up, then decaf is going to be useless to you. If youre just looking for a hot drink, then decaf may work fine for you.
Read Also: What Stores Sell Verismo Pods
Why There’s Caffeine In Decaf Coffee
First things first: What the hell is caffeine even doing in your decaf cup of Joe? She doesnt even go here. We have the nature of the decaffeination process to thank for this. Its long, complicated, and imperfect. It is almost impossible to remove all the caffeine from a coffee bean, Nathan Arnold, spokesperson for the Food and Drug Administration , tells SELF.
There are several methods of decaffeination, with the most common being what are called solvent extraction techniques, William Ristenpart, Ph.D., director of the U.C. Davis Coffee Center and professor of chemical engineering at the University of California Davis, tells SELF. Basically, after green coffee beans are harvested and dried but before roasting , they are soaked in a solution containing a solvent, usually methylene chloride or ethyl acetate, which binds to the caffeine molecules and leaches them out. Other solvent methods involve drawing out the caffeine using only water , or highly pressurized carbon dioxide .
There are typically multiple rounds of extraction that take place. The number of rounds and the other steps and chemical processes involved in each method vary. But across the board, it is not feasible to remove every last molecule of caffeine, Ristenpart says. In general, whenever youre doing a separation of chemicals, its very difficult to achieve 100 percent , and thats true for the caffeine in coffee beans.
Chemical Solvents Co2 And Water
Today, decaffeination is an intensive process that takes place at specialized facilities.
“There are a couple very large companies that own their own decaf plants, but beyond that every other company either contracts directly with a decaffeination company or they contract through an importer,” David Kastle, a senior vice president at the Canada-based company Swiss Water Decaffeinated Coffee, told Live Science.
Generally, decaffeination involves water-logging coffee beans when they’re still green so that the caffeine inside can be made soluble, meaning that it can be dissolved. But there are different ways of washing that caffeine out of the beans.
The first commercially successful decaffeination method was invented around 1905, by German coffee merchant Ludwig Roselius. According to Atlas Obscura, one bit of lore about the origins of decaf claims that Roselius received a shipment of coffee beans that was soaked in seawater. Instead of tossing the beans, Roselius decided to process and test them. He found that the coffee had been stripped of its caffeine content but still basically tasted like coffee, albeit a bit salty.
The chemist patented his decaffeination method in 1970 it’s still widely used today. According to NPR, crude caffeine can be salvaged during the supercritical carbon dioxide decaffeination process, which is used in sodas, energy drinks and other products.
Recommended Reading: How Much Caffeine Is In Sonic Iced Coffee
Caffeine Content Of Decaffeinated Coffee
To ensure product quality, manufacturers are required to test the newly decaffeinated coffee beans to make sure that caffeine concentration is relatively low. A caffeine content reduction of at least 97% is required under United States standards. There is less than 0.1% caffeine in decaffeinated coffee and less than 0.3% in decaffeinated instant coffee in Canada. To do so, many coffee companies choose to employ high-performance liquid chromatography to quantitatively measure how much caffeine remains in the coffee beans. However, since HPLC can be quite costly, some coffee companies are beginning to use other methods such as near-infrared spectroscopy. Although HPLC is highly accurate, NIR spectroscopy is much faster, cheaper and overall easier to use. Lastly, another method typically used to quantify remaining caffeine includes ultravioletvisible spectroscopy, which can be greatly advantageous for decaffeination processes that include supercritical CO2, as CO2 does not absorb in the UV-Vis range.
Both of these studies tested the caffeine content of store-brewed coffee, suggesting that the caffeine may be residual from the normal coffee served rather than poorly decaffeinated coffee.
Health Benefits Of Decaf Coffee
Despite having been demonized in the past, the truth is, coffee is mostly good for you.
Its linked with numerous health benefits, which are mainly attributed to its antioxidant content and other active substances.
However, the specific health effects of decaf coffee can be hard to determine.
This is because most studies assess coffee intake without distinguishing between regular and decaf coffee, and some dont even include decaf coffee.
Also, most of these studies are observational. They cannot prove that coffee caused the benefits, only that drinking coffee is associated with them.
Don’t Miss: How Much Caffeine Is In Sonic Iced Coffee
Your Complete Guide To How Decaffeinated Tea Is Produced
Caffeine occurs naturally in tea. For tea to be considered decaffeinated, the caffeine has to be removed. The tea industry uses 3 main methods to remove caffeine from tea leaves. Tea makers choose either the Carbon Dioxide, Ethyl Acetate or Methylene Chloride method. The method you prefer is a personal decision.
First, an important distinction. Decaffeinated tea and caffeine-free tea are not the same. Decaffeinated tea is made from actual tea leaves. All of the caffeine can never be removed from tea leaves and a small amount of caffeine remains, usually under 2%.
Meanwhile, caffeine-free teas are not made with actual tea leaves and do not contain any caffeine. The teas are herbal and include such varieties as chamomile, mint, hibiscus, rooibos and the like. Herbal teas really are 100% caffeine-free because they are made with herbs, spices and similar items and do not contain any actual tea leaves.
In the US, federal regulations dictate that decaffeinated products must have less than 2.5% caffeine. Most decaffeinated teas contain less than this amount.
Tea is more delicate than coffee so caffeine removal has to be done with caution. Since tea companies do not put the decaffeination method on the package, it can be difficult to find out. At teadog.com, we have obtained this information and included the decaffeination method for every tea we offer.
But Why Is It So Difficult To Make Good Quality Decaf Coffee
Lets be 100% completely honest with you as coffee roasters and sellers of coffee, decaffeinated coffee is really hard to make well.
The major problem is that the process of removing the caffeine from coffee beans without doing any damage at all or having an effect on the flavour and quality is still not perfect.
Characteristics of the same bean, both decaffeinated and caffeinated will be markedly different.
Which is why you need to pick and choose your battles with decaf coffee.
From a roasting perspective, its just hard to roast compared to normal beans.
The colour of unroasted normal beans are green, unroasted decaffeinated beans are much more brown in appearance.
We lose more control over our refined roasting process as a result, and roasting these beans can be a little inconsistent with each batch.
A lower moisture content within the coffee bean also speeds up the roasting process as there is less moisture to absorb the heat.
This results in beans that roast darker and faster than our standard caffeine-rich coffee.
The good thing for our customers and especially those who buy our decaf options is that we are perfectionists.
We wont settle for sub par decaffeinated coffee so that means instead of trying to offer a wide range of bang average decaf coffee, we instead refined our options to two blends that we can a) replicate consistently and b) provide a great coffee taste simply sans caffeine.
Recommended Reading: Which Decaf Coffee Brands Use Swiss Water Process
First What Is Caffeine
Caffeine is an alkaline drug that acts as a stimulant to the central nervous system. It is one of the most commonly used drugs on earth, and some statisticians believe that 95 percent of every adult human being on earth consumes caffeine in some form or another every day. In its pure form, its a white, crystalline powder with a bitter taste. It is perfectly safe for most people, and it would take 50 to 100 regular caffeinated cups to come close to killing a grown human being.
How To Remove Caffeine From The Coffee Beans
Coffee beans contain over 400 different molecules that give coffee its characteristic taste and smell.
The challenge of removing caffeine from the coffee beans is to leave as many flavors and odor molecules in them.
As early as 1906, Ludwig Roselius patented a method of extracting caffeine from coffee.
In the Roselius method, they soak the coffee beans in salt water or acid, the beans evaporated to open their pores and then washed with benzene chemical solvent.
Roselius used benzene mainly to remove caffeine effectively from coffee without harming other flavors and aromas.
They dont use Roselius method today, mostly because benzene is a carcinogen even in tiny amounts.
You May Like: Elevate Smart Coffee Reviews
How Do I Know If I Am Going Through Caffeine Withdrawal
Everyone experiences caffeine withdrawal differently. Some of the most common symptoms include emotional lability, headaches, breathlessness, shakes, and sweating. You may also have digestive issues.
Even though caffeine withdrawal manifests differently from person to person, caffeine withdrawal usually lasts from a few days up to a week.
What Is The Point Of Drinking Decaf Coffee Anyhow
For serious coffee lovers, decaf coffee may seem like sacrilege. Why drink coffee without that kick from the caffeine, right? But, there are lots of people for whom caffeine poses a real problem.
Drinking coffee while pregnant often means ditching the kick of your caffeinated beverage. When I was pregnant with both my kids, what I ate and drank became a HUGE concern for me. Its when I started drinking organic milk and gave up caffeine. It was an eye opening time of my life.
People who are elderly or have heart problems often have to give up caffeine as well.
And some people just dont respond well physically to too much caffeine but love the flavor of coffee itself. Rather than give up their favorite morning cup of coffee completely, they prefer to look for decaffeinated coffee brands instead.
Dont want to miss the next post?
Follow Turning the Clock Back on | |
Or join the for simple tips on going green!
Read Also: Sonic Cold Brew Calories
The Inventor Of The Decaffeination
The German coffee trader and founder of the still existing company Kaffee Hag, Ludwig Roselius developed the first decaffeination procedure for commercial quantities in 1903. His motivation was his suspicion of caffeine to be poisonous after his father, who was a heavy coffee drinker, died at a young age. To prevent more people dying from caffeine poisoning, he soaked raw coffee beans in salt water and extracted the caffeine with the aid of benzene.
Because of the carcinogenic benzene, the coffee he created with this method was probably more poisonous than the caffeine ever could have been but his product was indeed – more or less – decaffeinated. His caffeine-free coffee was a big success all over europa and until today, similar methods are being used for decaffeination – but without benzene.