Tuesday, July 9, 2024
HomeMakeHow Do You Make Homemade Coffee Creamer

How Do You Make Homemade Coffee Creamer

Homemade Flavored Coffee Creamer 20+ Flavor Combo Ideas

How to Make Homemade Coffee Creamer

Im one of those Would you like some coffee with your creamer? type people. Coffee in and of itself is boring and bitter to me. But I do enjoy its benefits upon occasion. So, to enjoy it, I must make it palatable. Enter: creamer. And lots of it!

However, store-bought creamer, even though it is so very yummy, is also so very unhealthy. Its chock full of yucky things like sugar and preservatives.

Since Ive been doing Trim Healthy Mama, I decided some on plan coffee creamer was in order. So I started making my own! And really, it could NOT be any easier. It contains so few ingredients, its so fast to whip up, and it tastes so very good!

Does Coffee Creamer Last Longer Than Half And Half

Since this coffee creamer is homemade and has no artificial ingredients or preservatives, it lasts the same amount of time as cream would in your fridge. I suggest keeping your homemade coffee creamer in an airtight jar or container in the fridge for up to 6-7 days. BUT, I can almost bet you it wont last that long!

Homemade Chocolate Almond Coffeecreamer


4 T. cacao powder 1 T. honey1-2 T. almond extract


Same as above, except start by adding first 4 ingredients before bringing to a low simmer. Once it starts to simmer, remove from heat and add almond extract.

This amount lasts me about a week in the fridge, but any longer than that, I can tell it has hit its shelf life. I work from home so drink a LOT of coffee while in my office. If you are a 1-2 cup per day person, you can easily cut this recipe in half or by a third. Ive made it so many times, I just eyeball the ingredients and it always turns out delicious.

To make dairy-free: You can absolutely use coconut or almond milk in place of the half and half, whatever your preference! Just note that the creamer will be a bit thinner in consistency.

Ingredient Note: I generally pick up my half and half at Costco for about $2.75/half gallon. They also have great prices on maple syrup and honey, if youre looking to buy in a larger amount.

Please share with us if you have tried something similar or have a favorite flavor combination!


I found the pitcher I use for my creamer at a vintage crafts and antiques show, but this glass pitcher from Circleware would work great and is inexpensive! Use a cheap plastic funnel to make pouring easier.

Looking for more delicious coffee-related recipes?

Looking for treats to pair with your coffee?

Don’t Miss: Does Diet Root Beer Have Caffeine

How Long Is Homemade Coffee Creamer Good For

Generally, it will last 7-10 days tightly sealed in your refrigerator.Youll also want to make note of the expiration date of your milk because that could affect it.

I found this on Mommy Savers.I had this great idea about adding that wee bottle of Baileys Irish Cream to the mix.

Yes, it is alcohol, but who says you cant start drinking at 7 am? Besides, its just a smidgen.But alas, Old Mother Hubbard went to the cupboard andthe cupboard was bare.

Darn it!I guess I already drank it and didnt even remember.

I had a small bottle of Godiva Chocolate liquor, but I wasnt in the mood for chocolate in my coffee.Yes, I know, GO FIGURE!

And WHY have I never thought about making our own creamer at home before??!!I guess its true that necessity IS the mother of invention.

This was SUPER easy, did the trick, and is less expensive than the fancy store-bought stuff.It will save you money and you know exactly the ingredients youre putting into it, none of those fancy words that you cant pronounce.

I may never buy creamer again.The full recipe is below.

Creamer Base Recipe #:

Homemade Coffee Creamer Recipe
  • 1 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 1 cup whole milk


Whisk together until fully combined or pour into a Mason jar, apply lid tightly then shake to combine. Store in the refrigerator. From here you simply add whatever flavorings to create your favorite sweet, flavored coffee creamer. Double even triple this recipe as you desire.

Curiously, this may appear to be a complicated way to make half and half, and youre partially correct. However, starting with heavy whipping cream makes a creamier, slightly thicker result, which I prefer and you may as well.

Note: If a recipe calls for a dry ingredient, such as cocoa powder, a spice like cinnamon or a thick ingredient like honey, pour all ingredients into a saucepan and heat over medium heat to dissolve those ingredients so they will be absorbed into the base. Pour the finished creamer through a fine sieve to remove any tiny solids or bits of spice that may remain. Now you wont have them floating in your coffee.


  • 2 cups Creamer Base #2
  • 4 tablespoons maple syrup
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 2 cups Creamer Base #2
  • 2 tablespoons cocoa powder
  • 4 tablespoons blue agave, sugar or maple syrup
  • 1 teaspoon almond extract
  • 2 cups Creamer Base #2
  • 3 tablespoons pureed pumpkin
  • 1 teaspoon ground pumpkin spice
  • 4 tablespoons maple syrup
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

French Vanilla

  • 2 cups Creamer Base #2
  • 4 tablespoons blue agave
  • 1 vanilla bean

Peppermint Mocha


Don’t Miss: Does Snapple Diet Peach Tea Have Caffeine

Whole 30 Paleo Coffee Creamer

So you are trying to eat a more natural diet. I understand because Im always trying to get away from anything processed to optimize my health.

But it can be hard to find recipes that goes along with this lifestyle that doesnt taste bland. Well, this recipe will hopefully change your mind when it comes to your cup of coffee.

Homemade Chocolate Coffee Creamer

Are you in love with chocolate? I totally get it because my mother is the same way. When I was a little girl, Id wake up to my mother standing in the kitchen in front of the fridge in the middle of the night pouring chocolate syrup into her mouth.

So if you love chocolate even half as much, then youll want to give this recipe a try. Youll mix a few ingredients to make something similar to hot chocolate. Then refrigerate until you are ready to use.

Read Also: How Is Nespresso Decaf Coffee Made

How Long Does Homemade Coffee Creamer Last

  • Get link
  • Email
  • Other Apps

I added chocolate milk chunks shavings of really good milk chocolate 2 bananas pineapple chunks strawberry jam for a kind of banana split ice cream. Cooked foods are perishable and should be stored in the fridge.

How To Make Coffee Creamer 5 Easy Coffee Creamers To Love Your Coffee Again A Sweet Pea Chef

Vanilla Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer Life S Ambrosia

Homemade Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer Don T Waste The Crumbs

Chocolate Chip Cookie Coffee Creamer

Homemade Flavored Coffee Creamer Recipe
  • Start with French Vanilla Creamer Recipe 2
  • Add 3 tbsp cocoa powder
  • Add 2 tbsp of light brown sugar
  • Warm it through on the stovetop till the cocoa powder and brown sugar dissolve completely
  • Store in a glass jar in the refrigerator

If you are looking to make a grown-up version you could even add a teaspoon or two of a liqueur such as Amaretto or Kahlua to any of these creamer recipes to give your post dinner coffee a nice pop!

Don’t Miss: Decaf Frozen Coffee Dunkin

Peanut Butter Cup Coffee Creamer

Peanut butter cups are a personal weakness of mine. Whoever created the flavor combo of peanut butter and chocolate was an absolute genius in my opinion.

So now that I know you can have that same great flavor combo to accompany your coffee, Im elated. It requires only a few basic ingredients and your coffee can be boosted to the next level of flavor town.

After viewing all of these homemade coffee creamers, hopefully, youll have found a few delicious ideas that will help you to enjoy your coffee a little more while saving you money.

Turmeric Lavender Coffee Creamer

This is a whole foods recipe that is sure to rock your socks and give your body a great boost first thing in the morning.

But dont let the turmeric throw you off. A lot of people dont care for the taste, but with the honey and turmeric, your body gets a great boost of anti-inflammatory benefits that it needs.

Also Check: Who Sells Grinds Coffee Pouches

How To Make Powdered Coffee Creamer:

First, mix together the dry ingredients.

Next, slowly drizzle the melted coconut oil over the dry ingredients.

I used a mason jar and just had to put the lid on the jar and shook everything together like crazy.

Finally, I then took a butter knife and broke up any bigger pieces, then shook again. You can also use a food processor if you prefer.

The heavier coconut oil tends to settle, so I suggest making this in a container that can be tightly sealed so you can mix it a bit before you use it.

What Variations Can You Make


Here is where you can let your creativity flow. Well get you started with a few popular choices. For more creaminess, use heavy cream instead of milk. To cut back on the calories a bit, you can use low-fat sweetened condensed milk and any regular milk you prefer to fit your dietary needs.

In terms of flavors, take a look at your baking cabinet. Spices like nutmeg and cinnamon and extracts like vanilla, peppermint, almond, and hazelnut can make delicious creamers. You can even whip up a seasonal pumpkin spice mixture or add chocolate syrup for a decadent treat. We recommend adding about two teaspoons of spices and extracts to each batch of creamer.

When adding dry spices like cinnamon, you may want to heat a small amount of the base creamer with the spice so it will dissolve and not leave you with a grainy texture. Using pure vanilla extract instead of imitation vanilla will improve the creamers flavor.

Adjust the measurements to your taste, and let your spice cabinet be your playground!

Don’t Miss: Folgers Decaf Coffee Caffeine Content

How Do You Use Powdered Coffee Creamer

To use your powdered coffee creamer, add 1 tablespoon to an 8-12 ounce mug and pour in hot coffee. You can add more creamer if you want.) Stir and enjoy!

What can you do with powdered coffee creamer?

  • Mix With Hot Chocolate.
  • Splash Over Some Fresh fruit.
  • Add To A Waffle Or Pancake Batter.
  • Add To Tea.
  • Add To A Cake Icing.
  • Mix With Cream-based Soups.

Is powdered creamer good for coffee? If youre one of the coffee drinkers that prefer your daily cup with added creaminess rather than black, powdered creamers are a convenient option since they have a long shelf life, dont have to be refrigerated, and are easily portable without the danger of unwanted spillage.

Can you use powdered coffee creamer instead of milk?

Things Youll Need If youre out of dry milk when a recipe calls for it, powdered coffee creamer is a logical substitute. Its taste is similar to milk, and some people prefer it in place of dry milk when theyre cooking or baking for its creamier flavor.

What Is Coffee Creamer

Believe it or not, coffee creamer is not just cream with added flavor.

Coffee creamer is a combination of flavoring and spices, sweetened condensed milk, and milk OR cream. The sweetened condensed milk and milk combine to give the creamer its richness, and this is what makes it so extra special once it gets mixed into your favorite coffee. If you cant find sweetened condensed milk, youre still in luck because I have you covered with my Bold Baking Basic recipe for sweetened condensed milk.

I even have a dairy-free condensed milk recipe for those who are looking to cut back on dairy!

Read Also: Does Mug Root Beer Have Caffeine

Questions You May Have

How long will homemade French vanilla creamer last?

French vanilla creamer can be stored in the refrigerator in an airtight container for up to 7 days.

What can I use instead of vanilla extract?

Vanilla bean, vanilla paste, or vanilla powder can be used in place of vanilla extract but extract is the easiest to use. The recipe uses 1 tablespoon of vanilla extract so instead of the extract, use 1 tablespoon of vanilla paste or powder. To use vanilla bean, use 1 whole vanilla bean.

Whats the difference between French vanilla creamer and vanilla creamer?

French vanilla usually refers to creamer thats rich and caramelized.

The Amaretto Coffee Creamer

Healthier Homemade Coffee Creamer

Yay! There should be more alcoholic coffee creamers in the world, am I right? Who doesnt want to start their morning all hyped up from coffee and boozed-up from, well, booze? Dont worry. Unless youre lighter than a feather, this creamer shouldnt do too much damage to your sobriety. What it will do is add a lovely almond amaretto touch to your morning brew. Try it here.

You May Like: Non Caffeinated Root Beer

How To Make It Dairy

Its pretty simple to make a dairy-free alternative to sweetened condensed milk and evaporated milk.

To make dairy-free sweetened condensed milk, simmer the following ingredients on the stove until it is nice and thick:

  • 1 can full-fat coconut milk
  • 2/3 cup granulated sugar

Dairy-free evaporated milk is also really simple. Let your favorite milk alternative simmer on the stove until it is reduced by half.

I hope you enjoy this easy to make coffee creamer recipe.

The Thin Mint Creamer

Heres another cookie one for everyone who enjoyed the other cookie inspired creations on this list. Girl Scout cookies are my guilty pleasure. I always have to get at least one or two boxes of them when the time comes, and thin mints are sublime. We havent had many minty creamers yet, so if you enjoy notes of mint and chocolate in your coffee, then try this here!

Also Check: Is There Caffeine In Snapple

Mint Chocolate Coffee Creamer

I thought of my sister when I saw this recipe. Since we were little girls, she always loved anything and everything that was mint chocolate. Even chap stickshed eat it off of her lips!

So I figured if there were any other people out there that loved mint chocolate even half as much as she does, then this recipe would be a hit.

Homemade Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer

How to Make Homemade Coffee Creamer with Cinnamon

Home in the Finger Lakes is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Some of the links below are affiliate links. This means that, at zero cost to you, I will earn an affiliate commission, that will help support this site. I love these products and think you will too!

  • Pin

Ahhh coffee, it makes mornings tolerable, and my to-do list achievable, and even adds a little extra pep to my afternoons. I generally like to drink my coffee black, but I do enjoy indulging in flavored sweetened coffee occasionally.

In the past when Ive wanted a caffeinated sweet treat, Ive tried store-bought creamers and sweeteners, that was never quite right, or Id find myself at the local coffee shop, paying way too much for my caffeine fix.

But one day I decided to try my hand at making homemade Italian sweet cream coffee creamer, and let me tell you it was life-changing! Now making the perfect cup of indulgently creamy and remarkably rich coffee at home is easier than ever.

Also Check: Can You Drink Coffee While Taking Eliquis

When Do You Add Creamer Before The Coffee Hits The Mug Or After

I add my coffee creamer after my coffee is brewed, this way I can stir it in and know the heat of the coffee will warm it through allowing it to fully favor the coffee. That said I dont really think theres a right or wrong to this. In other words, once you make these coffee creamers, feel free to use as much or as little as you want to make coffee taste the way you like.

How To Make Coffee Creamer

Im excited to tell you that this really could not be easier, because to make all 3 of these coffee creamer flavors you simply whisk together the ingredients.

For the Vanilla creamer, I like to simmer everything together over low heat to really infuse the milk. I do the same for the Baileys flavor, but for a slightly different reason, as this will gently cook off the alcohol content, but leave that rich flavor. The result for all 3 is the perfect thick rich coffee creamer dressed up with loads of flavor so no matter your mood, you can have a coffee flavor to match!

Read Also: Can I Drink Coffee After Wisdom Teeth Removal

Homemade Irish Cream Coffee Creamer

I’ve been meaning to make some Homemade Irish Cream Coffee Creamer for a while now. After all, it’s Mr. Gracious’ favorite. But I just honestly had no idea what flavors to combine. Finally after some research, some experiments, and some taste-testing from Mr. Gracious, I’m pretty sure I’ve got it!

Making your own homemade coffee creamer is a great way to save money, and this recipe only takes 20 minutes, so you don’t even have to give up your time to save that money!

The Chocolate Raspberry Coffee Creamer

How to Make Coffee Creamer 5 Easy Flavors | A Sweet Pea Chef

We had the white chocolate raspberry creamer. Here comes the chocolate raspberry coffee creamer in all of its chocolate and berry goodness. I love this for when I want a cup of coffee as a dessert after a meal. It imparts the perfect amount of dessert flavor without overpowering my brew. Find the recipe here!

Also Check: Does Diet Root Beer Have Caffeine


Most Popular