Tuesday, February 20, 2024
HomeEditor PicksBest Whiskey For Irish Coffee

Best Whiskey For Irish Coffee

Roe & Co Blended Irish Whiskey

The “Best” Whiskey for IRISH COFFEE? | Cocktail Taste Test

While this whiskey may not have been around for too long, it definitely shouldn’t be overlooked. Roe & Co says its Blended Irish Whiskey is named after a man named George Roe, who once had the largest distillery in Ireland that spanned more than 17 acres. While that historic distillery closed back in 1926, the Roe & Co brand helps the legacy live on by honoring Dublin’s roots in the thriving whiskey business. And thank goodness for that, as their Blended Irish Whiskey is one we would have never wanted to miss. Malt and grain whiskey are aged in bourbon casks that give off a fragrant aroma with a taste of pear and vanilla and an ultra-creamy finish.

This whiskey will not disappoint you in your Irish coffee either. To get an extra sweet finish, Roe & Co says to try whipping your cream with maple syrup and a drop of vanilla essence.

Connemara Original Peated Single Malt Irish Whiskey

This Connemara whiskey brings back the ancient tradition of whiskey making where the malted barley is dried over peat fires. It hypnotizes with an exciting peaty flavour and aroma.

The lightly golden whiskey does not frustrate with a one-dimensional smokiness. To the nose, the peat smoke is balanced by sweet floral notes with hints of honey and apple crumble. To the taste, it is warming and surrounded by notes of honey, cocoa, and malt. The finish is glorious, lingering with layers of peat smoke and honey heather.

However, it is not your average peat. Connemara bottles a unique peated whiskey experience. The taste is subtle and combined with some flowery goodness and honeyed sweetness

With its subtle peat and notes of cocoa, it will amplify the charred flavor and aroma of your coffee, making it one of the best whiskeys for an Irish coffee.

The Sexton Single Malt Irish Whiskey

It is one of the best-selling Irish single malt in America. It is very distinctive because of its beautiful bottle design that is made of black glass and hexagonal in shape.

The taste on the nose is malty and fruity with sherry sweetness while notes of apricots, honeycomb sweetness, dried fruit, lemon, and malt are felt on the palate. If you like your Irish coffee super-smooth this is the perfect whiskey for you.

You May Like: Can Coffee Cause Inflammation In The Body

A Brief History Of Irish Whiskey

The oldest known record of Irish whiskey goes back to 1405, roughly 90 years before the first known record of Scotch whiskey was written.

While traveling 1500 years ago, Irish missionary monks developed the process of distillation. When they returned to Ireland, they put their newly acquired skills to the test by distilling alcohol.

As far back as the 16th, 17th, 18th, and up until the 19th-century, Irish whiskey was one of the worlds most sought-after beverages. At its peak, the island had 88 licensed distilleries. Dublin was a whiskey metropolis in the nineteenth century, producing ten million gallons of whiskey per year, making it five times more popular than anything made in Scotland at the time.

However, the twentieth century posed several challenges to the category. When the world was at war, it was forbidden to use barley or coal for non-military purposes. As a result of these tough times, Irish whiskey producers and drinkers in the United Kingdom were classified as rebels by the British people, resulting in a decline in whiskey consumption across the British Empire.

Then came Prohibition, enacted in 1919 and lasting until 1933, eliminated our greatest export market. Then came WWII and a devastating trade war with Britain that practically shut down the whole British Empire, including India, Canada, and Australia as a market. A Scotch whisky boom was the final nail in the coffin.

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey

Irish Coffee

While we normally like our whiskey bold and tasting like barley or oak with maybe a touch of vanilla, we can’t get enough of this peanut butter whiskey and for good reason. According to Skrewball Whiskey, the flavor is completely unexpected, which we have to agree on. Like peanut butter, it’s the perfect combination of sweet and salty but never too overwhelming. Also, like peanut butter, it’s nice and smooth. For a whiskey that originally got its footing from a well-received cocktail at the brand’s Ocean Beach restaurant, it’s definitely worth a sip .

The flavor combo makes for the perfect whiskey to add to your after-dinner drink. This is what the brand calls its Skrewed Up Irish coffee, but really, it’s made the same as the traditional, only with this tasty peanut butter whiskey. To top it off, this sweet rendition definitely calls for some whipped cream on top.

You May Like: What Is The Best Coffee Bean In The World

Can Scotch Whiskey Be Used In Irish Coffee

A Scottish twist on the Irish Coffee, this warming and delicious after dinner drink is made with hot brewed coffee, Scotch whisky, brown sugar, and topped with fresh whipped cream.

Can you use single malt for Irish Coffee?

It combines both a single malt whiskey and a light grain whiskey, and it is aged for five years in bourbon and sherry casks. In this bottle, expect to enjoy tasting notes of honey and freshly baked oatmeal cookies. With flavors like this, you cant go wrong using Bushmills Original Irish Whiskey in your Irish coffee.

Can I substitute Scotch whiskey for Irish whiskey?

Irish whiskey has a smooth, round flavor, as opposed to the smoky quality of Scotch whisky. If you dont have Irish whiskey, substitute bourbon.

Can I substitute Irish whiskey for bourbon in a recipe?

As a result of its similarity to bourbon, whiskey can be used in its place. Whiskey can be substituted for bourbon on a one-to-one basis. To make this recipe, you should add the same amount of whiskey as bourbon.

The Busker Triple Cask Irish Whiskey

A newcomer to the scene, bringing a combination of quality and value is The Busker. With a blend of single grain, single malt, and single pot still, the result is a light and bright feeling whiskey with a smooth, creamy honey flavor.

Mixing it with your coffee effuses baking spices, vanilla, and dark chocolate aromas with subtle notes of cinnamon and toffee fudge, while the nose often leads off with tropical fruits.

Aging in three types of barrels bourbon, marsala, and sherry casks ensures you get the perfect experience out of your drink.

Read Also: What Is The Best Decaf Coffee To Buy

Buying Guide Of Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee

What are the key factors you look for when purchasing a high-quality Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee? We understand that it can be challenging to decide which one is right for your needs when there are so many options available. However, we have done all of this research and put together lists that should help narrow down your choices. You must also have a list of questions on your mind. Although Consume with Care has done everything we can to help you, it is still imperative for you to do your own research. You need to check out any relevant Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffees before buying them, so they are exactly what you need!

  • Does it make sense for you to invest in the Best Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee?
  • Which brand offers the best Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee in the current market for the money?
  • What are the advantages to buying Best Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffees?
  • Which factors should be considered when selecting the best products?

There are undoubtedly many questions you still have about the best Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee. The best way to find out the answers is to do your research and talk with someone who knows what theyre talking about. No one knows more about this topic than experts! Sources of information for you could include buying guides, word-of-mouth, rating websites, testimonials from previous customers who have purchased these products and online forums devoted solely to discussing topics related to Best Irish Whiskey For Irish Coffee.

Best Under $: Teeling Small Batch Irish Whiskey

The Best Irish Coffee You’ll EVER Have!

Courtesy of Reserve Bar

Region: Ireland | ABV: 46% | Tasting Notes: Baking spices, vanilla, dried fruit

The first whiskey distillery to open in Dublin in 125 years, Teeling launched in 2015 with this bottle as its flagship offering. Extremely smooth and rounded, thanks to some time spent in ex-rum barrels after initial aging in ex-bourbon barrels, this is the ideal whiskey for those who eschew spice in favor of a sweeter spirit. It has notes of baking spices and caramelized sugar on the nose, with flavors of vanilla and raisins on the palate. Typically hovering around $40, this Irish whiskey is a great buy, punching well above its price point. Try it in an Irish Coffee or sip it straight with some dark chocolate for a perfect after-dinner treat.

You May Like: Where To Buy Whole Bean Decaf Coffee

The 5 Key Elements Of Irish Coffee

The CoffeeSome people prefer light roast Colombian java while others only drink dark French roast, and you can pick pretty much any coffee for your cocktail. Although Morgan Carney, general manager and bar manager of Bostons Grafton Street, uses an extra bold roast, hes also used Americano and, for an iced version, cold brew. Flavored coffees are fine too, but if you go that route, the flavor of the coffee will be the dominant feature of the drink as opposed to the whiskey, says Kieran Aherne, regional manager at Fado Irish Pub. In that case, he advises, you may want to add less sugar. Whatever your preference, for classic Irish coffee, your joe needs to be HOT. Boil water and let it sit inside the glass for about 30 seconds. Then immediately add the hot coffee after you toss out that water. This will keep the glass hot and prevent your drink from cooling too quickly.

The WhiskeyFor this cocktail, Irish whiskey is a given. While Jameson and Tullamore D.E.W. are often used, you can choose any brand. The go-to whiskey at Grafton Street is Glendalough Double Barrel, which adds a peppery kick to the drink. Most of the time, youll want to choose a blended whiskey, rather than single malt or pot still, whose more robust flavors would overpower the drink. Just remember to adjust the amount and type of sweetener and cream you use to suit the flavor profile of the whisky and achieve a balanced drink.

Tullamore Dew Original Irish Whiskey

Tullamore D.E.W. Original Irish Whiskey stands proud as the first triple blended triple distilled Irish Whiskey.

The triple blend gives it a unique rich taste with sweet flavors coming from grain whiskey, fruit flavors coming from malt whiskey, and spice flavors coming from the pot still whiskey.

The triple distillation makes it extremely smooth and warming. It sits well on the palate for an almost refreshing feel. This makes it excellent for those that want an introduction to Irish whiskeys. It also makes it an excellent Irish whiskey for an Irish coffee.

Tullamore D.E.W. has charred wood undertones that pair perfectly with coffee, and the whiskeys overall rich flavor will add excitement to your cup of coffee. Its superb smoothness means that you can mix it with your coffee anytime.

Also Check: Who Has The Best Iced Coffee

Best Value: Slane Irish Whiskey

Region: Ireland | ABV: 40% | Tasting Notes: Caramel, vanilla, dried fruit

Slane hails from the Boyne River Valley, which was once home to many other distilleries, and is one of the few that has revitalized the tradition. Distilled on the grounds housing the old Slane Castle, this Irish whiskey is aged in a selection of three different casks: virgin oak, seasoned whiskey, and Oloroso sherry. Its bold and layered with flavors of caramel, vanilla, and dried fruit. With its rich history, complex flavor, and pedigreed musical ties , this affordable bottling is a steal.

It works in a variety of ways, says Alicia Yamachika, lead bartender at Nobu Honolulu. The three different casks it ages in all add a little something different to be enjoyed. Tame the spice with an ice cube or use its heft to your advantage in a cocktail like an old fashioned or a New York sour.

Related:The Best Whiskey Glasses, According to Experts

Im a big fan of Slane Whiskey. Its really lovely on its own, but because of its soft and approachable profile, it works well in lighter whiskey cocktails. And you cant beat the price point.Prairie Rose, Editor

Best Irish Whiskey Brands

The Teeling Whiskey Irish Coffee

Nea Pantry

Nea Pantry is a freelance writer living in downtown Toronto. She writes full-time for Honest Brand Reviews, alongside a variety of copy writing projects for local and international businesses. When not writing, you can find her in the kitchen whipping up a batch of vegan muffins.

A former student-journalist and graduate student, Justin has a long history in writing, editing, and publishing. While he loves reading and writing, Justin is also passionate about sports, music, and fitness.

Edited on

Don’t Miss: How Much Caffeine In Snapple Diet Peach Tea

Proper Twelve Irish Whiskey Ireland

Owned by MMA fighter Conor McGregor, Proper Twelve makes a full-bodied Irish coffee thats rich without being too sweet. It has bitter chocolate, toasted grain, and sourdough crust aromas, and creamy, chocolatey flavors. The spirit, a blend of bourbon-cask-aged grain and single malt whiskey, is also notable on the palate but doesnt overpower. Average price: $26

Writers’ Tears Copper Pot Irish Whiskey

Made by the famous Walsh whiskey company, this single pot still and single malt whiskey is, as the name suggests, distilled in copper pots and matured in ex-bourbon casks. This results in beautiful honey and fruity notes.

Its a little rough when drunk straight, which may put off casual whiskey drinkers. Combining it with a hot cup of your favorite coffee, a taste of honey develops on your palate with mellow notes of golden malt and vanilla with a hint of oak.

This leaves a sweet and long finish. Its also used to create signature cocktails like the Tears Royale. Truly one of the most versatile whiskey brands on the list.

This brand has a funny history. Legend has it that the name came from a man named Paddy who used to walk his famous whiskey from bar to bar having fun and indulging anyone who wanted to have a taste of his famous drink.

Everyone then started referring to it as Paddys whiskey. His spirit sure lives on to date. Its made with all the three main styles of Irish whiskey: single malt, single grain, and single pot still.

In terms of taste, its sweet on the palate with a little vanilla, rosewater, and butterscotch notes. It also leaves the nose oily and fresh with floral and fruity notes. Another tasty whiskey for the perfect Irish coffee. If you love it spicy and dry with a little black pepper and oak finish, Paddy Irish Whiskey might just be your new favorite tipple.

Read Also: Which Coffee Maker Keeps Coffee The Hottest

Use Two Sugars For Better Irish Coffee

A combination of granulated sugar and brown sugar makes for a cup of joe with balanced sweetness. Just a teaspoon of each keeps the cup from being cloying, which the molasses brings the whiskeys own sweetness to the forefront. Use unsweetened whipped cream to keep the sweetness contained in the coffee and avoid a sugar hangover later in the day.

What Whiskey Should I Use For My Irish Coffee

How To Make The Irish Coffee | Jameson Irish Whiskey

A time-honored tradition is upon us: the National Holiday for Irish Coffee. While many sources tell different tales of where this practice actually started, it is a drink loved by many and celebrated on January 25. .

The recipe is simple . Black coffee is poured into your mug. Whiskey and at least one leveled teaspoon of sugar is stirred in until it is fully dissolved. The sugar is essential for the liquid cream to float on top. Or at least that is one way to do it.

My favorite whiskeys for Irish Coffee:

Photo: Albany Distilling Co


This award-winning rye whiskey is made by the Albany Distilling Company with 100% New York State-grown ingredients. Dark and delicious, this whiskey boasts 2-4 years aged in Oak Barrels and an earthy sweet finish, making it a perfect pairing for your black brew.


This whiskey is made with incredible attention to detail from PM Spirts. Aged 8 years with a focus on the bourbon, but with subtle hints of vanilla and apple and nuts. This whiskey will compliment your coffee and linger in the back of your mind long after the cup is empty.


Typically aged up to 6 years, this blended Kentucky bourbon whiskey is finished for up to 6 months in port wine casks. This gives the whiskey and incredibly smooth and sweet taste. Pouring this into your cup of joe will truly make a heavenly drink.



Read Also: How Does Caffeine Help With Migraines

Can I Mix Whiskey With Coffee

One of the simplest and oldest ways to make coffee is with Irish Coffee. You can get it with either sugar or Irish cream, and its a blend of coffee, whiskey, and sugar. Perfect for after dinner or as a nightcap, this bittersweet hot cocktail is the perfect cocktail to end a great meal. However, decaffeinated coffee might be the best option.

Bushmills Original Irish Whiskey

There are a lot of different whiskeys out there that are modern and fancy. While we always enjoy trying those, sometimes all you really need is the original. Bushmills Original Irish Whiskey is the go-to spirit that gets the job done time and time again. According to Bushmills, it’s the “oldest licensed whiskey distillery in the world” as it received its distillery license back in 1608. Naturally, this brand knows what it’s doing, which is why it is on our list of the best whiskeys for Irish coffee. It combines both a single malt whiskey and a light grain whiskey, and it is aged for five years in bourbon and sherry casks. In this bottle, expect to enjoy tasting notes of honey and freshly baked oatmeal cookies.

With flavors like this, you can’t go wrong using Bushmills Original Irish Whiskey in your Irish coffee. And you don’t have to do anything fancy here either. Bushmills says to use your favorite coffee when making this hot drink and leave the rest up to the whiskey.

You May Like: Where To Buy Roasted Coffee Beans


Most Popular

Where To Buy Joe Coffee